Questions on Amy Ruiz

So it seems the questions about the improper hiring of Amy Ruiz constitute the most serious allegations Sam Adams is facing.

I don’t think this is something that Amy Ruiz needs to feel guilty about. It may have been her understanding that she was hired for her competence and it is even possible she is a very capable public servant. The question here is whether she was improperly hired, in spite of other better qualified candidates, because she was investigating Adams’ affair with Breedlove.

These interviews with Portland Mercury do much to set the record straight, but I don’t think answer that key question. Of course, the Mercury is engaged in a battle for their credibilty (which I think is unnecessary). The onus is on the mayor’s administration to demonstrate that Amy Ruiz wasn’t hired to stymie her ongoing investigation. At best, the mayor should apologize for what is an uncomfortably tone deaf understanding of how the hire would look in public.

Honestly, I think Amy Ruiz is as much a victim in this as Bob Ball. If the mayor asked you to take a gig as a policy planning analyst, and you thought you could be an asset to the city, wouldn’t you take the gig? The appearence of impropriety is the fault of the employer, not the employee.

Why Sam Adams Should Resign

As you may have heard, Portland Mayor Sam Adams has gotten himself into a little bit of trouble. Adams, the openly gay mayor of this openly gay city, has admitted to lying about having a sexual relationship with Beau Breedlove. For those of you living in a cave (or not Portland, which might be worse) the two met when Breedlove was only 17, although they both claim they didn’t start having sex until after he turned 18. The scandal initially made news in 2007, when rumors surfaced that Adams’ relationship with Breedlove had more to it than the claimed “mentorship.” Adams denied these rumors until he was confronted with a story that was recently published by the alternative weekly the Willamette Weekly.

There are a lot of interesting things this scandal suggests about Portland, sexual politics in the US and gender relations. However, those things are not my area of expertise (who knew I had one?!), so instead of offering thoughts along those lines, I’d like to try to answer the question: “Should Sam Adams stay on as Portland’s mayor?”I wanted to take a few days to get to answering this question in depth, because I don’t really know much about Adams and didn’t want to jump to conclusions before hearing the whole story.

After taking some time to think it through, I’ve decided Adams should step down. The sexual relationship that Adams had with Breedlove is ethically and legally dubious, but not ultimately a political crime worth losing office for. In the course of covering up the affair, Adams allegedly committed three political crimes, all of which rise to the level of being penalized by a removal from office. Each of these allegations is worthy of investigation by the Attorney General. Although I don’t believe politicians sexual lives should be subject to public scrutiny, I believe Adams has lost the credibiilty necessary to effectively stay on as major. As tends to be the case in politics, the cover-up was much worse than the original crime.

Didnt Anyone Learn from This Guy?

Didn't Anyone Learn from This Guy?

The Willamette Week article outlining the history of the reporting on the affair, that eventually caused Adams to confess, makes three substantially sourced allegations. First, the article outlines how Adams used the rumors of the relationship to undermine a political opponent who presented a legitimate challenge to his mayor race. Bob Ball, who is also gay, and was considering his own mayor run made news in 2007 for bringing up the allegations to other Portland political players. Adams and his supporters used Ball’s mention of the allegations as a cudgel to accuse Ball of peddling smears and playing into anti-gay stereotypes. Ball was forced out of the race – although the current reporting has vindicated his initial reaction.

At the time, Adams said he was mentoring Breedlove, and both men said their relationship was just platonic. And Adams claimed Ball was engaged in a dirty tricks campaign.

“I have been the target of a nasty smear by a would-be political opponent,” wrote Adams in a Sept. 18, 2007, email released to the public. “I didn’t get into public life to allow my instinct to help others to be snuffed out by fear of sleazy misrepresentations or political manipulation.”

Would Adams have won a race against Ball if he had been honest about his indiscretions? Portland voters never had a chance to decide.

Second, the article alleges that a reporter covering the story for the Portland Mercury was hired by Adams to hush up a continuing investigation after he was elected.

Adams hired Portland Mercury City Hall reporter Amy Ruiz to be his adviser on sustainability and strategic planning. Ruiz, 28, acknowledged in a Jan. 15 interview that she has no experience in sustainability, planning or government. “This town has a million and a half urban planners, and I’m not one of them,” she says.

Ruiz’s new salary—$55,000—is substantially more than she made at The Mercury.

Mayors and city commissioners frequently hire people whose enthusiasm exceeds their experience. But it was what Ruiz had done as a reporter—or more specifically, what she had not done—that brought into question Adams’ decision to hire her.

Ruiz continued to work on the story after the rumors died down, and was rewarded with an important city job that was beyond her experience. This is perhaps the most serious allegation contained in the story: it involves bribery and cronyism. If Adams misused public funds, and gave discresion over public planning, in exchange for Ruiz’s silence he deserves to be prosecuted. An investigation should be launched into whether Amy Ruiz was improperly hired, that should look at whether other, more experienced candidates were interviewed and, if they were, why they weren’t hired.

Last, the article alleges that Adams was trying to place his associate and colleague on the City Council Randy Leonard as the Police Chief. Leonard is now calling for an investigation into the Breedlove scandal, and must see his own political future in serious jeopardy. The article alleges that Leonard spoke out in favor of Adams during the campaign and in the course of doing so, became aware of the truth of the allegations. Apparently, Leonard was willing to trade his silence for future political considerations. Perhaps, for this reason, the police union is calling for Adams resignation.

Again, neither Adams’ sexual preferences or history with Breedlove are reasons for him to step down. But if L’affaire Breedlove was unimportant enough that Portlander’s should be cool with it, Adams should have leveled with us before we elected him. And he certainly should have done so before using city funds to quiet investigations, or defamed a potential political opponent. I know little of Adams’ politics, which I think actually makes me more inclined to judge the matter fairly. That said, I find it hard to believe that Portland can’t find a similarly progressive and capable individual to fulfill our mayoral functions.

UPDATE: The story has moved a lot over the past few days. Check out The Oregonian and Willamette for ongoing updates.

UPDATE: Some more reporting on the Ruiz aspect here, here and here. Ruiz seems much better about dealing with the issue transparently than Adams has been. That said, I think there is still cause for an investigation.

Sam Adams: All He Wanted to Do Was Breedlove

A sex scandal has erupted in Portland with hilarious cartoon names. Some of the names involved: Sam Adams, Bob Ball, Mark Merkle, Mark Weiner, and, at it’s center, a (potentially underage at the time) gay paramour Beau Breedlove. You couldn’t have come up with a better name if you tried.

Not This Guy

Not This Guy

I’m not much of a city politics bluff, so I can’t really comment on the specifics of the scandal without doing some more research, but I found this blog post to be a really useful rundown of the arguments for and against the mayor stepping down.

Here is the rundown.

This Guy

This Guy